Friday, November 16, 2012

Notes - Strategies for Addressing Limits to Rationality

The following are notes for Working Toward Sustainability Ethical Decision making in a Technological World.
  • Addressing the limits to rationality
  • acknowledge our limits
    • actively seek information that promote sustainable behavior/complex issues in general
    • proactivity to understand more
    • receive further information with an open mind
Becoming Environmentally Informed
  • knowledge is the first step, finding academic literature
    • social, economic, and environmental dimensions
    • ecological footprint
      • measure of the environmental impact of a person's daily activities
      • environmental consumption i.e. transportation, home expenditure, food consumption
      • calculators have been devised to keep track of
        • sources of energy used
        • land, water resources
        • vary in detail but useful as rough guidelines
        • carbon footprint
          • amount of greenhouse gases produced
        • fails to account for differences in social groups as they are statistical averages
    • Paul Ehrlich's IPAT equation
      • (I) Ecological Impact
      • (P) Product of Population
      • (A) Affluence
      • (T) Technology
      • attempt to think systematically about how factors combine to affect processes and resources
      • overgeneralization
  • environment is tied to wealth, per capita resource used increases with affluence, wealthier nations have larger footprints than poor ones
    • link not always straightforward, some wealthier nations are greener than less wealthy ones
    • i.e. Europe's footprint is smaller than United States
Becoming Socially and Economically Informed
  • Integral measure of factors can't be measured by just environmental impacts
  • Fair Trade practices
    • products made by non exploitative practices
    • tries to ensure employees reap stable socioeconomic benefits
  • Sustainability involves balancing ecological, social, and economic factors and weighing the relative importance of one another
  • Intergenerational communities vs familial communities decision making
Systems Thinking
  • (CAS) Complex adaptive systems
    • systems that are rapidly changing, large and hard to model
    • vital to choose attention to vital information not just vivid
  • Most states include critical thinking as a core aspect of education
    • solve disconnect of memorization and understanding
    • in general the public's critical thinking skills is not at a high enough level to process information in long term ways
  • Synthesis
    • standard practice
      • Divide problems into smaller more manageable components and view them separately
      • education system reflects this, division of subjects i.e. arts, mathematics, sciences, etc
    • Long term decisions are often multi disciplinary
    • acknowledge that we have to sometimes view problems as a whole instead of breaking them down
  • Scale
    • think of the scale of consequences
      • effects globally
      • effects community
      • effects personally
  • Stocks and Flows
    • Recall from Georgescu-Roegen's distinction between stock resources and fund resources
      • stock resources - draws from a limited reserve
      • fund resources - near infinite, or self replenishing
    • stocks
      • immediate effects of an event
    • flows
      • consequences of events/effects of a stock
    • apply to global climate change
      • minimize greenhouse gas
        • gas emissions is the stock
        • side effects of global warming such as climate change is the flow
        • Must consider timeframe, there is delay between when gas emissions are released and when effects occur
        • consider additional actions such as heating cycle of earth, to figure out when heat gets capture from gas emission and held for longer than normal
  • Feedback loops
    • presence of feedback loops
    • negative feedback loops
      • systems tend towards equilibrium through loops that return the system to normality
    • positive feedback loops
      • systems grow uncontrollably
      • more likely to cause problems as it destabilizes equilibrium
      • catastrophe can occur when it hits a boundary or limiting condition
      • i.e. bacterial growth
        • unrestrained bacteria growth increases population of bacteria
        • bacteria consumes resources in the area
        • causes drain on resources, death of host area
  • Resilience
    • ability to respond to change
    • fail safes implemented
    • system archetypes
      • common patterns of loops/behavior of a system
      • helps to understand what fail safes will be effective

No comments:

Post a Comment